About this English edition

This is the English edition of my Japanese commentary, last revised on October 5, 2026. That revision removed unverified CFTC claims from the confirmed facts and separated the scope of the FCA and ASIC publications from private surveys and industry estimates. The linked sources were checked again for this translation on November 6, 2026. This is not a comprehensive statement of the law in every country.

What is confirmed

The publications discussed here do not establish a single, worldwide regulatory regime for retail prop evaluation services. Each concerns a different activity and stage of oversight.

  • The UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) reviewed algorithmic-trading controls at FCA-regulated principal trading firms. Its August 21, 2025 publication assesses compliance with existing requirements. It expressly creates no new requirements; it is not the introduction of a new regime for retail prop evaluation services. Read the FCA review.
  • The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) reported action against finfluencers suspected of unlawfully promoting high-risk products or providing unlicensed advice, including concerning CFDs and OTC derivatives. The cited announcement should not be presented as a warning aimed specifically at prop firms. Read ASIC’s announcement.
  • Regarding the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the Japanese article’s review did not identify primary evidence for the previously mentioned proposal to introduce registration requirements across prop firms, or for the specific consultation deadline previously described. I therefore do not treat those claims as confirmed. The CFTC’s general instructions for submitting comments are not evidence of such a proposal.

That distinction matters. Below, I separate what these sources say from my own view.

My view as a prop trader

USK: I’ve been seeing a few stories about regulation around the prop trading industry.

Toreko: Regulation? I’d like to know what’s changing.

USK: For the CFTC, I couldn’t identify primary evidence in the original source review for the registration proposal or the specific comment deadline I’d previously seen mentioned. So I decided not to use those claims as confirmed facts.

USK: What I could verify from the FCA was a review of algorithmic-trading controls at regulated principal trading firms. That is different from announcing new rules for retail prop evaluation services.

USK: ASIC has also acted against unlawful finfluencer activity involving high-risk products. But I’d be careful not to turn that particular announcement into a claim that ASIC issued a warning directly against prop firms.

Toreko: So there are developments in different countries, but they aren’t all about the same thing.

USK: Exactly. There is also a private survey worth separating from those official publications. Finance Magnates reported that nearly 70% of respondents to a PipFarm survey thought prop firms should be regulated. The survey covered 3,127 of PipFarm’s own clients worldwide in January 2025.

This was a survey of one company’s customers, reported by industry media. It was not a public, industry-wide representative survey. Finance Magnates’ February 12, 2025 report explains the sample and result.

Toreko: Nearly seven out of ten is quite a lot. How did you feel about it?

USK: Having received more than 70 payouts at the time of the original commentary, I can understand the feeling. In my experience, some firms still leave traders unclear about how payout rejections or account freezes are decided. I’ve had appeals accepted, and I’ve also heard from people whose appeals weren’t.

That payout count and those experiences are my own account in the original article. They are not a current running total, an industry success rate, or a promise that another trader will receive a payout.

Toreko: When the protections are unclear, a lot of the work of judging a firm falls on the trader.

USK: That’s the difficult part. I’d welcome clearer oversight and more dependable routes for raising a complaint. But the protections and complaint routes that actually exist still depend on the service and jurisdiction.

USK: Finance Magnates Intelligence also estimated that roughly 80 to 100 prop firms left the market during the 2024 industry reshuffle. That’s an industry-media estimate, not an official regulatory statistic. It also doesn’t mean regulation was the only reason those firms left.

The February 27, 2025 report describes the 2024 estimate. A later DataLab report from April 20, 2026 uses a period from January 2024 to the first quarter of 2026. These are differently framed estimates, not two separate totals to add together.

Toreko: Which direction would you like regulation to take?

USK: Personally, I’m broadly in favour of clearer oversight. I also think the gap could widen between firms that take compliance seriously and those that don’t. How a firm responds to regulatory developments is one factor I’d consider when choosing one.

Toreko: That makes sense. I’d be interested to hear what develops next.

USK: I’ll write again when I have something useful to add.

Opinion, not legal advice

These are my personal views. Regulatory treatment, eligibility and available protections vary by jurisdiction, product and business model. Check the relevant regulator and the firm’s current official terms before relying on a claim about protection or oversight.

Sources and further reading

The Japanese article’s linked news coverage is a dated report: Prop industry news for September 28 to October 4, 2026 (Japanese).

When choosing a firm, I look beyond regulation at its actual rules, payout conditions, support and my own experience. Compare prop firms through practical use, payouts and rules (Japanese).